Baked Goods

Many of our baked goods come from recipes we tested at home—long before our cookies and fry pies were on our shelves. Wondering what makes the difference? View flavors and nutrition information below.

<
>

Cookies

At Yoder’s Baking Company, we make baked goods differently. No preservatives and only fresh ingredients ensure you’ll get the best cookies on the market shelves!

Classic Cookie

Classics

  • Chocolate Chip

  • Oatmeal Raisin

  • Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip

  • Peanut Butter

  • No Bake Peanut Butter Chocolate

  • Monster

  • Snickerdoodle

  • Molasses

  • Chocolate Crinkle

  • Sugar Cookie

Sandwich Cookie

Sandwich Cookies

  • Oatmeal Sandwich

  • Chocolate Whoopie Pies

  • Pumpkin Whoopie Pies

Fry Pies

Homestyle goodness is yours in every bite of our freshly made fry pies. These handheld desserts will become party favorites after your first order.

Fruit Fry Pie

Fruit Fry Pies

  • Black Raspberry

  • Red Raspberry

  • Lemon

  • Blueberry

  • Apple

  • Peach

  • Cherry

  • Strawberry Rhubarb

Breads

It’s hard to pass up on the flavor of freshly baked bread. We make a variety of sweet and savory breads—plus rolls and quick breads—for all your sandwich and snacking needs.

Traditional Bread

Traditional

  • English Muffin

  • White

  • Wheat

  • Sour Dough

  • Multi-Grain

  • Raisin Cinnamon

  • Cinnamon

  • Dill

  • Oatmeal

  • Italian Cheese

  • Jalapeno Cheddar

  • Salt-Rising

Rolls

Rolls

  • White

  • Wheat

  • Vanilla Frosting Cinnamon Rolls

  • Maple Frosting Cinnamon Rolls

Quick Bread

Quick Breads

  • Banana Nut

  • Blueberry

Homestyle Pies

We make all our pies with fresh ingredients, including real fruit, real cream, and crust made in-house! Taste the real difference in homestyle pies from Yoder’s Baking Company.

Fruit Pies

Fruit Pies

  • Apple

  • Dutch Apple

  • Red Raspberry

  • Pecan

  • Blueberry

  • Cherry

  • Peach

  • Strawberry Rhubarb

  • Rhubarb

  • Pumpkin (Seasonal)

Cream Pies

Cream Pies

  • Custard

  • Banana Cream

  • Peanut Butter

  • Chocolate Peanut Butter

  • Chocolate Pudding

  • Lemon Cream

  • Coconut Cream

  • Raspberry Cream

Cakes & Rolls

We have something for every dessert lover with our delectable cakes and rolls. Try our moist, flavorful sweets for parties, get-togethers, and other events.

Sheet Cakes & Muffin

Cakes

  • Carrot Cake

  • Banana Cake

  • Chocolate Sheet Cake

pumpkin roll

Sweet Rolls & Bars

  • Pumpkin Roll

  • Pumpkin Bars